A general-purpose ERP is built around items, quantities and prices. That model works for a shop that sells boxes of screws. It strains when the thing you sell is a log that is measured, not counted, and then cut into something else.
This is not an argument against ERPs. It is a list of the places where timber stops fitting, so you can judge for yourself.
The short answer
Use a general ERP for what it does well: accounts, payroll, tax, purchase approvals. Use timber software for what happens between the forest and the buyer: tally, stock, sawing, containers and reconciliation. The mistake is expecting one to do the other’s job without months of customisation.
Where a generic ERP fits timber well
- Accounts and tax. Ledgers, invoices, GST or VAT, bank reconciliation.
- Payroll and HR. Nothing timber-specific here.
- Approvals and purchasing workflow. Generic and mature.
If you only trade finished goods in fixed pack sizes, a generic system may be enough.
8 places where timber breaks the generic model
| # | In a generic ERP | In timber |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Stock is an item with a quantity | Stock is individual logs or pieces, each with a mark, length, girth and grade |
| 2 | Quantity × unit price | Price follows measured volume (CBM or CFT) and often grade or girth band |
| 3 | One unit of measure per item | Two or three at once: pieces, CBM, CFT, sometimes tonnes |
| 4 | A bill of materials with fixed ratios | Round logs cut into sawn sizes, with a yield that changes by log, species and sawyer |
| 5 | Stock moves between warehouses | Stock moves yard → mill → container, and the same wood changes form on the way |
| 6 | Goods receipt equals invoice | Loading tally vs discharge tally, with a variance you must explain |
| 7 | A shipment is a document | A container or truck is a record of its own, tied to a tally and a consignment |
| 8 | Data entered at a desk | Measured at the yard or loading site, often without signal |
Each row on its own can be solved with custom fields and scripts. Together they are why “configuring the ERP for timber” turns into a project.
Three examples that show it
1. The maths is not multiplication. A round log’s volume depends on how you measure it. With Huber’s formula, a log of 140 cm mid girth and 3.5 m length is 140² × 3.5 ÷ 125,660 = 0.546 CBM, which is 19.3 CFT. The Hoppus method gives about 21.5% less for the same log. Your buyer’s contract decides which one applies, and the software must apply it the same way every time. More on this in Hoppus vs true volume and Huber’s formula.
2. Cutting changes the stock. When round logs go through a saw, the output is sawn timber in several sizes, plus off-cuts. The number that matters is the recovery or outturn percentage. A generic bill of materials assumes a fixed ratio. A sawmill needs the real one, per job.
3. The two tallies never agree exactly. Loading figures and discharge figures differ a little. What you need is a record that keeps both and shows the difference, without confusing mill conversion loss with shipment shrinkage. That is the idea behind timber consignment reconciliation.
The hidden cost: “we will customise it”
The usual path is to buy the ERP, then pay for custom modules for tally, volume and yield. Three things tend to follow:
- The custom parts sit outside the vendor’s normal updates, so every upgrade needs checking.
- Yard staff do not use a desk system, so tallies go into spreadsheets or paper first and get typed in later.
- The people who understand the customisation become a single point of failure.
None of this is certain for every company. It is the pattern to ask a vendor about.
10 questions to ask any software vendor
- Can I enter length and mid girth per log and get CBM and CFT without writing formulas?
- Can I choose Huber or Hoppus per buyer or contract?
- Does it handle both round logs and sawn sizes, and convert between them?
- Can I record the yield of a sawing job and see it by species?
- Is a container or truck its own record, linked to a tally?
- Can I keep loading and discharge tallies side by side and see the variance?
- Does the mobile app work without signal and sync later?
- Can I send a buyer a read-only link to a tally or shipment?
- Does a new user need a consultant, or can the yard team start in a day?
- What happens to my customisations when the software updates?
If three or more answers are “we can build that”, you are looking at a project, not a product.
Where LumberLinq fits
LumberLinq is a timber management system built around these steps: round and square log tally with CBM, stock by yard and mill, process and yield tracking, transport units and containers, and reconciliation. It has Android and iPhone apps that work offline, and secure share links for buyers. It does not try to replace your accounting package.
Start free or see it in a short demo.
This is general guidance, not advice on a specific purchase. Check any software against your own tallies before you commit.
Related: Timber management software buyer’s checklist · Lumber and timber inventory management software guide · Timber tally sheet format · Sawmill recovery and outturn percentage